Since writing the above post I have checked the OS 25" map for 1908 and this has put a spanner in the works. The S&F box in the photo is clearly on the down side south of overbridge 56, while in 1908 the box was still on the down side but north of the overbridge. Therefore this box cannot be the one on the map!
However, on the 1908 map there is a small square building shown in just the position of the box in the photo, and it could be about 14ft square.
From February 27th to July 9th 1893 the deviation line over the new MSC bridge was open for goods traffic, but the old line was still open for passengers. So for at least five months there must have been a double junction between the two lines immediately to the north of the platforms. A new lever frame with 30 levers was ordered from Crewe signal works in August 1892, and a new cabin and apparatus was reported to the Loco Committee in March 1893. Twenty two of the 30 levers were in use. Obviously this was needed to work the double junction, and must be the cabin shown on the 1908 map. This new cabin would be out of site behind the overbridge in the photo, if indeed it existed then. It would presumably have been a standard type 4 cabin, but no evidence has been found to confirm this. The old S&F was still in situ, out of use in 1908. So far so good.
It does indeed seem to be the case that both spans of overbridge 57 (Moss Lane) are visible, putting the date of the photo after 1892. Phillip Millard states that the date of the photo is 1913 or later. Assuming this to be correct, and noting that the S&F SB appears to be in use, what has gone on here? A box abolished in 1893 still in use post 1913? There are only two explanations that fit the facts, as far as I can see:
Either the S&F box was retained after 1893 as a porter's room or similar, and was not actually in use for signalling purposes when the photo was taken. However this does not seem terribly likely at such a small passenger-only station, and in any case the levers and block shelf seem to be visible through the open window.
Or the 1893 box was abolished and the 1870 S&F box reinstated as the station signalbox sometime after 1908. In fact, a new 10-lever frame was ordered from Crewe works in 1909, so this might be the date of reinstatement.
Are we certain that it is a photo of Moore? I can't see where else it could be. |